How many?

Counting is somewhat fundamental to our lives. A key feature of Human intelligence is our ability to define the number of a given artifact with which we are presented. To my knowledge, no animal exhibits this capability to any significant extent. Indeed, I believe that an Amazonian tribe was discovered whose counting system went “one, two, many”.

But even we, in the Western world, can run into trouble with numbers …

Big numbers lead us astray. Scientists avoid the problem by always working in powers of ten, but most of us like words. Up to a million is OK, but then there is a problem. We now often hear references to billions and trillions – particularly with reference to national debts etc. How many is a billion? Most of us would say 1 followed by 9 zeros. However, this is not universal. Originally, the word “billion” was coined to replace “a million million” – “bi” being the prefix for 2. So, a billion then had 12 zeros. Later it was changed in some countries [e.g. US and UK], but elsewhere the old meaning has stuck. So, that is why scientists are so fussy.

I am good at counting. I can obviously do so indefinitely in English and I can make a brave effort in French, German and Italian. They do make it hard in some languages. In France, for example, everything is OK up to sixty, but seventy is “sixty-ten”, eighty is “four twenties” and ninety is “four twenties and ten”. All very complicated. In some other French speaking countries [e.g. Belgium and parts of Switzerland] they have fixed is and have proper words for seventy, eighty and ninety.

Number bases are interesting. We almost always use base 10. I assume this is just a consequence of human beings having 10 fingers and thumbs [does anyone know why we have this number?]. Computer people use binary [base 2], octal [base 8] or hexadecimal [base 16]. Ultimately it is arbitrary what number base is used in any context. I have often thought that, for everyday purposes, base 12 might be handy, but I cannot imagine people accepting the change. If you can move all your fingers and thumbs independently [I cannot do that], you can count in binary. That means that you can count up to 1023 on your fingers or up to 31 with one hand]. Neat trick eh?

I have got caught out with numbers from time to time. A few years ago, I was doing a seminar in Israel. Before the event, the technician was setting up the PA. He was walking around the room with the mike saying three words in various combinations. Being curious, I asked him what they meant. He answered: “One. One, two. One, two, three.” So, I can now say hello/goodbye and thank you and count to three in Hebrew.

Want to stay up to date on news from Siemens Digital Industries Software? Click here to choose content that's right for you


0 thoughts about “How many?
  • You mentioned German. Although not a native speaker, I know enough to be dangerous…

    German is interesting in that a number like 24 is said as “4 and 20” (remember “four and twenty blackbirds”?) To my native German-speaking wife that sounds perfectly normal, and to my bi-lingual daughters either the English or German approach sounds normal. But once you get over 100 in German, e.g. 224, the number would be “two-hundred four and twenty”. So it goes biggest-smallest-middle. Once you do it a lot it’s not so hard.

    And the billion/million thing, also in German. In German, a million is the same (10 ^ 6), but a billion is (10 ^ 12) – as you’d said, “a million million”. A “milliard” is the German term for (10 ^ 9). When we’re discussing international economies & debts in our household, these orders of magnitude, and the terms we use with each other, become important. My billion is not my wife’s billion.

    Last thing – dates. I’m one of the few Americans who writes all dates like 2011-11-03, always with the 4-digit year format. The typical American 11/03/11 can be confusing to some, especially when dealing with international customers. Of course you can remove all doubt by writing “November 3, 2011” when it’s critical.

  • Fair comments Dan. I agree about German, but at least they’re consistent. I mainly use numbers in German for ordering beer, so I rarely get far into double figures [I don’t have that many friends!]. In Old English, I believe that numbers were different. There is a children’s song in which “four and twenty blackbirds were baked in a pie”.

    I am with you on dates. I write them “readable and unambiguous” – i.e. 3 Nov 11, 3-nov-11, 3 November 2011 – or sortable and unambiguous – i.e. 20111103 – or maybe “sortable and logical if you’re smart” – i.e. 111103. I blogged about this a while back:

Leave a Reply

This article first appeared on the Siemens Digital Industries Software blog at