The first 12 notes of a song

If you are reading and come across a word that you do not understand, and you feel suitably motivated, it is straightforward to look it up in a dictionary. This is something that I do a lot, as part of my motivation for reading is to improve my own communication skills. Yet another reason why my Kindle is my friend. It is less easy if you just hear a word, as, in English, it can be challenging to find the right spelling, particularly when the speaker is lazy about pronunciation.

The problem gets more interesting when, instead of a word, it is a piece of music that you want to identify …

Nowadays, technology gives us some interesting ways to identify music. If the song you hear has words, then all you need to do is Google a suitably long sequence and you will most likely find yourself directed to one of the numerous song lyric sites. On one occasion, I mis-heard the words and Googled what I thought that I had heard. The lyrics site to which I was taken was so smartly designed that it cataloged mis-heard variants of songs as well as the accurate words.

If you have a smart phone, you just need the right app. I use Shazam, but I am sure there are others. All you do is let the app “listen” to the music for a few moments, then it accesses some remote database and comes back with the answer. I am constantly amazed at its precision. It seems to be able to identify quite obscure music, from only a short sample and seems impervious to quite high levels of background noise. I guess this is a high tech implementation of The Old Greys Whistle Test.

Many years ago, I heard about a much lower technology approach. A dictionary was published, which listed many thousands of pieces of music. The authors claimed that, if you could hum the first few [I think it may have been 12] notes of a song, you could look it up in this dictionary. All you needed to do was right down these notes in the following way:

  • The first note is written as “X”.
  • Each subsequent note is written thus:
    • “S” means that it is the same as the previous note.
    • “H” means that it is a higher pitch than the previous note.
    • “L” means that it is a lower pitch than the previous note.

So you end up with a string that looks like this: XSSLLSSLHSS…

Then you look through the dictionary where songs are listed as strings like this in alphabetical order.

I was very taken with the elegance of this idea and have often wondered whether that dictionary was successful and whether it still exists.

Want to stay up to date on news from Siemens Digital Industries Software? Click here to choose content that's right for you

Leave a Reply

This article first appeared on the Siemens Digital Industries Software blog at https://blogs.sw.siemens.com/embedded-software/2012/02/16/the-first-12-notes-of-a-song/